To British Catholics the Church is not controlled by a foreigner. She is controlled by the Vicar of Christ. It would be just the same if St. Peter were still there to-day, and he was a Palestinian Jew. If a Frenchman or an Englishman were elected, no Italian Catholic would regard the Pope as Pope in the light of any foreign nationality. I cannot be at once subject to two opposed monarchs as national sovereigns, but I can be subject to my earthly ruler in temporals and to the representative of Christ in spirituals. Until the Reformation all Englishmen were subject to the Pope, yet were filled with great love for their country. You would not presume to say that there was not a single loyal Englishman in the time of Henry V. Yet all England was Catholic then, and any Catholic can do to-day what Catholics could do then. The only Catholics in the world who owe temporal allegiance to the Pope are those who actually reside in Vatican City, over which, and over which only, he has the full rights of a temporal ruler. If, through unjust ambition, the Vatican City State were to despatch an immense army to invade Australia, it would be the duty of Australian Catholics to join the Australian army and defend their country. That ought to make it clear that spiritual allegiance to the Pope does not interfere with our citizenship.
Radio Replies Volume 1 by Rev. Dr. Leslie Rumble MSC and Rev. Charles Mortimer Carty
🙏 PayPal Donation Appreciated
Related Posts:
- But does not your allegiance to the Pope conflict with your duty as a British subject? Remember that your Church is controlled by a foreign temporal king.
- Then, as a rule, will they not elect an Italian Pope?
- So the fact remains that you must submit to a foreigner?
- But where was unity even within the Catholic Church during the fourteenth century, when there were three Popes at once, each with his own section of adherents?
- The Church of England is Catholic because she is sending missionaries throughout the whole world as far as possible.
- Ought not the Catholic Church to elect a Britisher as Pope sometimes, just to prove to the world its Catholicity?
- The constitution was changed by that very Augustine. The Church in England before him was not in communion with Rome.
- You say that the Pope is not swayed hy national considerations. In a war between Italy and England, would not his sympathies be with Italy?
- You say that the Pope is not swayed hy national considerations. In a war between Italy and England, would not his sympathies be with Italy?
- We Protestants look upon the King, not as head of the Anglican Church, but as the representative of the British Empire.
- Biblical Reasons Why Catholics Make Use of Images
- Must not the Pope always be an Italian?
- Understanding the Fundamental Differences between the Church of England and the Catholic Church
- Birth Control - The Catholic Church has the Answer
- If Catholicism is true, why are the most backward countries Catholic, and the most enlightened and progressive countries Protestant?
- The Holy Ghost and the Church - Primer Catechism
- England I could still be Catholic had not men taken to thinking.
- During all the centuries only one Englishman has been considered as "best fitted." Is not that a reflection on the learning and ability of our nation?
- Understanding the Role of Saint Peter in the Establishment of the Church
- But surely the majority of the millions of Protestants would realise their mistake, if indeed they are mistaken. They would on any other important subject.