What Is the Use of Referring Workers to State Authority When It Seems to Protect the Wealthy?

Brief Catholic Answer

• The Catholic Church encourages workers to engage with state authority as a means of promoting justice, not as an endorsement of any specific political party or regime.
• State authority, in Catholic teaching, is seen as a legitimate structure for organizing society and protecting the common good, even if it is imperfectly executed.
• Workers are called to unite and use lawful means, such as voting, to influence the state and advocate for policies that align with justice and human dignity.
• The Church recognizes that state authority can be corrupted or biased toward the wealthy, but it remains a necessary institution for societal order.
• Catholic social teaching emphasizes the role of workers in shaping just governments through active participation in civic life.
• Referring workers to state authority reflects the Church’s belief in the potential for reform and the moral obligation to pursue the common good through legitimate means.

Detailed Catholic Answer

The Church’s View on State Authority

The Catholic Church has long held that state authority is a natural and necessary component of human society, rooted in the need to promote the common good. This perspective is grounded in the belief that humans are social beings who require organized structures to live in harmony and justice. The Church does not view the state as inherently opposed to the interests of workers but as an institution that can be directed toward justice through proper governance. In Catholic teaching, the state’s legitimacy comes from its ability to serve all members of society, particularly the vulnerable, including workers. However, the Church acknowledges that state authority can be misused or corrupted, often favoring the wealthy or powerful. Despite this, the Church insists that the state remains a critical mechanism for achieving societal order and protecting human rights. Workers are therefore encouraged to engage with the state, not to blindly submit to it, but to actively shape its policies. This engagement includes using lawful means to advocate for fair wages, safe working conditions, and respect for human dignity. The Church’s position is informed by its commitment to subsidiarity, which holds that higher authorities, like the state, should support and not supplant the efforts of smaller groups, such as workers’ associations. By referring workers to state authority, the Church emphasizes the importance of civic participation in building a just society (CCC 1880-1882).

The Role of Workers in Shaping Just Governments

Catholic social teaching places significant responsibility on workers to actively participate in civic life to ensure that state authority reflects justice. This participation is not limited to accepting the status quo but includes the right and duty to challenge unjust governments. The Church teaches that workers should unite, forming associations or unions, to amplify their collective voice. These groups can exert lawful political influence, such as voting or advocating for legislative reforms, to address systemic inequalities. The Church has consistently supported the right of workers to organize, as seen in papal encyclicals like Rerum Novarum (1891), which defends the formation of workers’ associations. By engaging with state authority, workers can push for policies that protect their dignity and promote equitable distribution of resources. The Church does not endorse any particular political party but urges workers to evaluate candidates and policies based on their alignment with moral principles. This call to action reflects the Church’s belief that justice is not achieved passively but through deliberate and lawful efforts. Workers are thus seen as agents of change, capable of redirecting state authority toward the common good. The Church’s guidance is clear: workers must use their collective power to vote unjust governments out and support those committed to justice (CCC 1913-1915).

Addressing the Bias Toward the Wealthy

The criticism that state authority primarily protects the interests of the wealthy is not dismissed by the Church. Catholic teaching acknowledges that sin and human failing can corrupt institutions, leading to policies that favor the powerful over the marginalized. The Church has repeatedly critiqued economic systems that prioritize profit over human dignity, as seen in Centesimus Annus (1991), which warns against unchecked capitalism. However, rather than advocating for the abolition of state authority, the Church calls for its reform. Workers are encouraged to challenge structures that perpetuate inequality by engaging in lawful activism, such as strikes, protests, or political campaigns, provided these actions respect the common good. The Church also emphasizes the principle of solidarity, which binds all members of society to work for the good of each other, including the wealthy and the poor. By participating in the state’s processes, workers can advocate for laws that curb excessive wealth accumulation and protect the vulnerable. The Church does not view the state as inherently aligned with the wealthy but as a neutral institution that can be shaped by the moral choices of its citizens. Workers, therefore, have a moral obligation to confront biases within the state through active and lawful means. This approach reflects the Church’s hope in the possibility of systemic change guided by justice and charity (CCC 1928-1933).

The Principle of Subsidiarity and Workers’ Rights

Subsidiarity is a cornerstone of Catholic social teaching that directly informs the Church’s guidance on workers and state authority. This principle holds that higher authorities, such as the state, should not interfere with the responsibilities of smaller groups, like workers’ unions, unless necessary to protect the common good. In practice, subsidiarity means that workers should have the autonomy to organize and address their concerns without undue state interference. However, when larger systemic issues, such as unjust labor laws or economic exploitation, require intervention, the state has a role to play. The Church encourages workers to collaborate with state authority to enact policies that uphold their rights, such as fair wages and safe working conditions. Subsidiarity also implies that workers should not rely solely on the state to solve their problems but should take initiative through their own associations. The Church views workers’ unions as vital expressions of subsidiarity, enabling individuals to collectively advocate for their needs. By referring workers to state authority, the Church is not suggesting passive dependence but active collaboration to ensure that the state fulfills its role in promoting justice. This balance between autonomy and cooperation is essential to the Church’s vision of a just society. The principle of subsidiarity thus empowers workers to shape state authority while maintaining their own agency (CCC 1883-1885).

The Moral Duty to Vote and Participate

The Church places significant emphasis on the moral duty of all Catholics, including workers, to participate in civic life, particularly through voting. Voting is seen as a concrete way to influence state authority and hold governments accountable for promoting the common good. The Church teaches that Catholics must evaluate political candidates and policies in light of moral principles, such as respect for human dignity and the preferential option for the poor. Workers, in particular, are called to support leaders who prioritize fair labor practices and economic justice. The act of voting is not merely a civic right but a moral responsibility to contribute to the establishment of just governments. The Church also encourages workers to educate themselves on political issues to make informed decisions that reflect Gospel values. By participating in elections, workers can challenge governments that perpetuate inequality and support those committed to systemic reform. The Church’s call to vote is rooted in the belief that state authority is not fixed but can be shaped by the collective will of its citizens. This perspective underscores the importance of workers’ engagement with the state as a means of advancing justice. The Church’s guidance on voting reflects its broader commitment to active citizenship as a path to social change (Gaudium et Spes, 75).

The Role of Solidarity in Workers’ Advocacy

Solidarity, another key principle of Catholic social teaching, plays a central role in the Church’s guidance for workers engaging with state authority. Solidarity calls for a sense of shared responsibility among all members of society, regardless of economic status. For workers, this means uniting not only among themselves but also with others who seek justice, including policymakers and even employers. The Church teaches that solidarity requires workers to advocate for policies that benefit not just their own interests but the common good of all. By engaging with state authority, workers can promote laws that protect the vulnerable, such as minimum wage standards or workplace safety regulations. Solidarity also implies that workers should approach their advocacy with charity, seeking dialogue rather than division. The Church recognizes that conflict between workers and the wealthy or powerful is often inevitable, but it encourages resolution through lawful and respectful means. By fostering solidarity, workers can transform state authority into a force for justice rather than a tool of the elite. The Church’s emphasis on solidarity reflects its belief in the interconnectedness of all people and the potential for collective action to create a more equitable society. This principle guides workers to see their engagement with the state as part of a broader mission to build a civilization of love (CCC 1939-1942).

Historical Examples of Catholic Worker Movements

The Church’s encouragement for workers to engage with state authority is not merely theoretical but has been demonstrated through historical examples. In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, Catholic worker movements, inspired by Rerum Novarum, emerged across Europe and the Americas. These movements organized workers into unions and advocacy groups that lobbied for labor reforms, such as the eight-hour workday and child labor laws. In Poland, the Solidarity movement in the 1980s, led by Catholic workers like Lech Wałęsa, challenged an oppressive state and contributed to democratic reforms. These efforts were grounded in Catholic social teaching, which supported workers’ rights to organize and influence state authority. The Church provided moral and spiritual guidance to these movements, emphasizing the importance of lawful and nonviolent means. Historical Catholic worker movements demonstrate that engaging with state authority can lead to significant social change, even in the face of entrenched power. The Church continues to draw on these examples to inspire workers today to advocate for justice through civic participation. These movements also highlight the Church’s consistent teaching that workers have both the right and responsibility to shape state authority. By studying these examples, workers can find practical models for effective engagement with the state (CCC 2430-2435).

The Church’s Critique of Unjust Governments

The Catholic Church does not shy away from critiquing governments that fail to uphold justice, particularly when they favor the wealthy at the expense of workers. Papal teachings, such as Laborem Exercens (1981), emphasize that governments must prioritize the dignity of labor over economic gain. When state authority becomes an instrument of oppression, the Church calls for reform through lawful means, such as voting or advocacy. Workers are encouraged to hold governments accountable by supporting policies and leaders that reflect moral values. The Church also teaches that Catholics have a right to resist unjust laws or policies, provided this resistance is nonviolent and respects the common good. This critique is rooted in the Church’s belief that all authority, including the state’s, is ultimately subject to God’s law. By referring workers to state authority, the Church is not endorsing every government action but urging workers to transform unjust systems from within. The Church’s critique of unjust governments underscores its commitment to justice as a universal principle. Workers are thus called to be discerning in their engagement with the state, supporting what is just and challenging what is not. This balanced approach reflects the Church’s hope in the possibility of redeeming flawed institutions through moral action (Evangelium Vitae, 70).

The Importance of Lawful Means

The Church consistently emphasizes that workers’ engagement with state authority must be conducted through lawful means. This guidance is rooted in the belief that respect for legitimate authority promotes social order and prevents chaos. Lawful means include voting, forming unions, participating in peaceful protests, and advocating for legislative reforms. The Church teaches that these methods are not only effective but also morally upright, as they respect the dignity of all involved. Workers are cautioned against resorting to violence or illegal actions, which can undermine the common good and harm their cause. The Church’s emphasis on lawful means reflects its commitment to the principle of justice, which requires fairness in both ends and methods. By working within the law, workers can build credibility and gain broader support for their efforts. The Church also recognizes that laws themselves can be unjust, in which case workers are called to advocate for their reform through legal channels. This approach ensures that workers’ engagement with state authority remains consistent with Christian values. The Church’s insistence on lawful means is a practical and moral framework for achieving lasting change (CCC 1897-1904).

The Church’s Hope for Systemic Change

Ultimately, the Church’s guidance for workers to engage with state authority is rooted in hope for systemic change. Catholic teaching holds that human institutions, though flawed, can be reformed through the collective efforts of morally guided individuals. Workers are seen as key agents in this process, capable of redirecting state authority toward justice and the common good. The Church’s hope is not naive but grounded in the belief that God’s grace works through human action to transform society. By participating in civic life, workers contribute to the gradual building of a more just world. The Church encourages perseverance, recognizing that change may be slow and met with resistance. This hope is reflected in the Church’s long history of supporting labor movements and advocating for social reforms. Workers are called to trust in the possibility of progress while remaining steadfast in their commitment to moral principles. The Church’s vision of systemic change is one of collaboration, where workers, state authorities, and other societal groups work together for the common good. By referring workers to state authority, the Church invites them to share in this hopeful mission of renewal (CCC 1916-1917).

Balancing Individual and Collective Action

Catholic teaching emphasizes the importance of both individual and collective action in workers’ engagement with state authority. Individually, workers are called to educate themselves on social issues, vote conscientiously, and live out their faith in their workplaces. Collectively, they are encouraged to form associations that amplify their voice and influence. The Church teaches that neither individual nor collective action is sufficient on its own; both are needed to effect meaningful change. For example, an individual’s vote is significant, but its impact is magnified when combined with the efforts of a united group. The Church also recognizes that workers may face personal risks, such as retaliation from employers, when advocating for change. In such cases, collective action through unions or other groups provides strength and protection. The balance between individual and collective action reflects the Church’s understanding of the human person as both unique and inherently social. By engaging with state authority in both capacities, workers can address immediate concerns while contributing to broader societal reform. This balanced approach ensures that workers’ efforts are both personal and communal, rooted in the Church’s vision of human dignity (CCC 1878-1880).

The Role of Faith in Workers’ Advocacy

Faith plays a central role in the Church’s guidance for workers engaging with state authority. Catholic workers are called to approach their advocacy with a sense of mission, trusting that their efforts are part of God’s plan for justice. Prayer and reflection are encouraged as means of discerning how to act in accordance with Gospel values. The Church teaches that faith provides the moral clarity needed to evaluate political and economic systems critically. For example, workers can draw on Matthew 25:31-46 to prioritize the needs of the poor and marginalized in their advocacy. Faith also offers hope, sustaining workers through the challenges of confronting unjust systems. The Church encourages workers to see their engagement with state authority as a form of witness to Christ’s teachings. By grounding their actions in faith, workers can maintain integrity and avoid being swayed by partisan agendas. The Church’s emphasis on faith underscores its belief that true justice is rooted in God’s law and love. This spiritual foundation strengthens workers to pursue change with courage and conviction (CCC 1807-1810).

The Church’s Support for Workers’ Rights

The Catholic Church has a long history of defending workers’ rights, which informs its guidance on engaging with state authority. Papal encyclicals, such as Rerum Novarum and Laborem Exercens, articulate the Church’s commitment to the dignity of labor and the rights of workers. These rights include fair wages, safe working conditions, and the ability to form unions. The Church teaches that state authority has a responsibility to protect these rights through just laws and policies. When governments fail to do so, workers are justified in advocating for change through lawful means. The Church’s support for workers’ rights is rooted in its belief that labor is not a commodity but a human activity that reflects the dignity of the person. By referring workers to state authority, the Church is urging them to hold governments accountable for upholding these rights. The Church also provides practical support through Catholic organizations that assist workers in their advocacy efforts. This commitment to workers’ rights reflects the Church’s broader mission to promote human dignity in all aspects of life. Workers can draw on this rich tradition as they engage with state authority to seek justice (CCC 2419-2425).

The Global Perspective on Workers and State Authority

The Church’s guidance for workers is not limited to any one nation but applies globally, reflecting the universal nature of Catholic teaching. In different countries, state authority takes various forms, from democracies to authoritarian regimes, each presenting unique challenges for workers. The Church encourages workers worldwide to engage with their respective systems in ways that are lawful and contextually appropriate. In democratic societies, this may involve voting and advocacy, while in oppressive regimes, it may mean discreet forms of resistance or international advocacy. The Church’s global perspective is informed by its experience with diverse political systems and its commitment to the universal dignity of the human person. Papal teachings, such as Pacem in Terris (1963), emphasize that all people have a right to participate in shaping their societies. Workers are thus called to collaborate across borders, sharing strategies and support through global Catholic networks. The Church’s global outlook ensures that its guidance for workers remains relevant in varied political and economic contexts. By engaging with state authority, workers contribute to a worldwide movement for justice and human dignity. This universal approach reflects the Church’s mission to build a global community rooted in solidarity and love (CCC 1905-1912).

Practical Steps for Workers’ Engagement

The Church offers practical steps for workers seeking to engage with state authority effectively. First, workers should educate themselves on their rights and the political processes in their country. This includes understanding labor laws, voting procedures, and the platforms of political candidates. Second, workers are encouraged to join or form unions to amplify their collective influence. Third, they should participate in civic activities, such as attending town hall meetings or writing to elected officials, to voice their concerns. Fourth, workers should collaborate with other groups, including faith-based organizations, to build broader support for their causes. Fifth, they are called to evaluate policies and leaders based on their alignment with Catholic social teaching, particularly the principles of justice and the common good. Sixth, workers should remain committed to lawful and nonviolent means, even when faced with opposition. These steps provide a clear framework for workers to engage with state authority in a way that is both practical and principled. The Church’s guidance empowers workers to take concrete actions that advance justice while remaining faithful to their values (CCC 2238-2243).

The Long-Term Vision for Workers and Society

The Church’s guidance for workers engaging with state authority is part of a long-term vision for a just and humane society. This vision is rooted in the belief that all people are called to live in communion with one another, sharing the goods of creation equitably. Workers play a critical role in this vision by advocating for systems that prioritize human dignity over profit. The Church teaches that engaging with state authority is not a one-time act but an ongoing commitment to building a civilization of love. This requires patience, as systemic change often takes time and faces resistance. Workers are encouraged to remain steadfast, trusting that their efforts contribute to God’s kingdom on earth. The Church also emphasizes the importance of educating future generations about justice and civic responsibility. By modeling active engagement, workers can inspire others to participate in shaping state authority for the common good. The Church’s long-term vision is one of hope, where workers and all members of society work together to create a world that reflects God’s justice and mercy. This vision guides the Church’s call for workers to engage with state authority as a path to lasting change (Caritas in Veritate, 67).

Conclusion: The Call to Transform State Authority

The Catholic Church’s guidance for workers to engage with state authority is a call to transform society through active and lawful participation. Rather than viewing the state as an unchangeable force aligned with the wealthy, the Church sees it as an institution that can be shaped by the moral actions of its citizens. Workers are empowered to unite, vote, advocate, and collaborate to ensure that state authority serves the common good. This engagement is grounded in the principles of subsidiarity, solidarity, and justice, which provide a moral framework for workers’ efforts. The Church acknowledges the challenges, including systemic biases and unjust governments, but remains hopeful in the possibility of reform. By participating in civic life, workers fulfill their moral duty to build a more equitable society. The Church’s support for workers is both practical and spiritual, offering guidance and inspiration for their advocacy. Historical and global examples demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach in achieving meaningful change. Ultimately, the Church invites workers to see their engagement with state authority as a mission to advance God’s kingdom through justice and love. This call to action remains as relevant today as ever, urging workers to be agents of transformation in their societies (CCC 1910-1912).

🙏 Support Catholic Answers – Donate via PayPal Now!

• donate monthly
• donate once only

Select a Donation Option (USD)

$10.00 (p/m) $50.00 (p/m) $100.00 (p/m) Other (p/m)

Enter Donation Amount (USD)